Wednesday, January 11, 2012

Beauty and the Mess

Recently a dear friend (and mama) rode in my car, but not first without my sincerest apologies for the state of the car, which looked something like this:


*The coffee cup in the back seat contains a banana peel. I discovered this when taking the photo... It's still in the car.

It's not like I thought she'd be offended, but I still felt compelled to hide the mess as I tossed trash and coffee cups into the backseat. She insisted it was fine, and in fact said something surprising. She told me it made her feel better. She had so far only seen the inside of my house which is kept, or appears to be kept in perfect order. One of my closest friends had never really seen my mess. This got me thinking...about mom blogs.

Every mom I know, including myself, reads mom blogs.
There are even celebrity mom bloggers. They write eloquently, post exquisite photographs, journal their Food-Network-worthy dishes, knit, crotchet, sew and paint, all while teaching their dozens of whimsical children at home...
And it is lovely.

It really, really is.
I don't mean to satirize mom blogs.
As an artist, I live to create beauty and to breathe it in and I am often inspired by these creative mamas.
Neither am I condemning the blogging mamas themselves.
I am one of them.
I'm no celebrity, but I have definitely projected, through my blog and through my posts, a picture of a beautiful life.
I am only suggesting that we think twice about the standard we create when we post only the good stuff. 

For example, another friend of mine posed a question about one mom blogger in particular, asking, "How do you think she does it all, and still has time to home school!?"
With my current season being full--with writing and music and school and a family--several friends have made the same comments to me: "How do you do it all?"
I can promise you this:

She doesn't.
I don't.

That "it all" you're so surprised we can do, is not the "it all" you imagine or that is displayed through a few well cropped photos and highlights from the week. We look with fascination at the mom who has it all together. She documents the meals she crafts, but not the dirt beneath the oven, she features the serene and never the chaos.

In turn, other mothers, regular mothers, tired mothers, new mothers, mothers with sick kids or stressful jobs or people like me who have a very, very low capacity for stress are left discontent, disheartened and wondering what mistake we must be making that our cups aren't overflowing with these lovely moments. What my cup overflows with is coffee...that I've stuck in the microwave 3786493 times because I'm freaking EXHAUSTED and I keep forgetting that it's in there.

Like I said, this is not a campaign against mommy blogs, and especially not a campaign against presenting lovely and beautiful things. I mean, I'm a big fan of loveliness: creativity, wooden toys and eyelet dresses, picnics in the sun and handmade goodness.
I think it's valuable open our eyes to beauty.

But it's also valuable to open our eyes to the mess...to acknowledge the mess...embrace the mess..to even blog the mess (Messy Mondays anyone?) and I'm going first:

I've decided to share with you 10 examples of blog life vs. real life. I hope you are inspired by both the beauty and the mess.
Keep in mind, the "mess" here isn't even close to the messiness that exists in my life, but just hasn't been caught on camera!

#1 - My Beautiful Home

Pristine, no? well this was taken when NO KIDS WERE HOME.
Would you like to see my front porch?


In case you were wondering, that is a rug from inside, a rained on sock and some pumpkins from October. I have no idea how long the rug or the sock have been there, but I'm sure my neighbors do and obviously the pumpkins are from...well...October... and they are moldy.


#2 - Homeschooling


This is a picture from that one year I home schooled...



...This is a picture of the girls at their public school. Post homeschool burn out.


#3 - Wooden Toys


Wooden abacus, wooden puzzle. The types of toys I long for my children to play with.



Plastic VW Bug from Goodwill and a Barbie from Walmart. The toys my kids actually play with.


#4 - Food:

One morning, I made a frittata and I posted a picture of it.



Every Saturday Sometimes, when I sleep until 9:30 in a little, the girls come into my room and ask for breakfast. Drool still fresh on the pillow and without opening my eyes, I manage to mumble, "Go ahead and get a snack out of the fridge...like a piece of bread." And they do. Sometimes they add jelly.
Not jelly I made myself. Not even organic.
Straight up grape jelly.


#5 - Costumes:

One year, I stayed up until 2am crafting this very sweet blog-inspired owl costume...that my daughter wore one time.


The next year, I bought a cheaply made yet overpriced and slightly scandalous Wonder Woman outfit off the internet and my daughter wore it 6 days in a row


#6 - Enriching Activities:


One day I made paint. It was cute, and my kids had so much fun!



A different day I stared at Facebook for hours!
As evidenced by this picture I found on the camera while preparing for this very post, my bored-out-of-her-mind child had resorted to playing with my camera without me even realizing it.
This happens more than finger-painting with cornstarch.


#7 - Homemade Clothing:


One Easter I made this dress out of old sheets. How very mom blogger of me!
I probably hand-make all of my children's clothes!



I didn't make this shirt... Er, or the bed, obviously.


#8 - Family Photo

This was one of our Christmas photos. Gosh I'm such a serene mother goddess in my flowing skirt and side bun.



This was me on Christmas. And most of the time, really. Not gonna say anything else about having posted this, other than yes, I realize it was a bold move.


#9 - Happy Children


Look at my kids during this forced impromptu moment!
They are like this all of the time!



No, actually this is what they're like most of the time.

The list could have been twice as long, with a picture for every situation...


For example, all of this healthy/organic/allergen free food that is also very expensive. 
So expensive in fact, we have to cut costs elsewhere--like replacing our broken refrigerator door pieces with duct tape.
(Hey, it works!)
But I want to leave you with this:



#10 - The Garden


The vegetable garden.
It is peaceful and lovely.
It is satisfying and nourishing.
It is blooming and it is plentiful.
 It is a summer garden.
 Other times, it looks like this:



Not so beautiful.
And guess what? This is what it looks like most of the year.

And this, my mama friends, is the lesson. Most of our lives are not fingerpaint and frittata.
Much of the time, our lives are rained on socks and old banana peels, tears and defeat, life held together with duct tape with glory and beauty sprinkled here and there.
Some don't even have the time for discontentedness--they have bigger troubles, like lack of housing or very ill children.

So yes, I am thankful for beauty.
I am also thankful for the mess.
For the moments not captured in a blog.
I'm thankful for the time my daughter told me she wished I wasn't her mom, because despite the hurt, I was able to hold her and let her cry it out, and model unconditional love and forgiveness...
Or that time I said something equally ridiculous ("You better clean your room with a cheerful spirit!") and I was able to model humility and repentance and my 5 year old heard "I'm sorry" straight from her mother's lips.
I'm thankful for this mess.
I'm thankful for the "winter garden" when the ground seems hard and cold, but important things are happening just beneath the surface.
I'm thankful for the "summer garden" when we bloom and laugh and when our cup overflows...


And, at the end of the day, by the grace of God, there is love, despite the beauty or the mess.
And for this I am grateful.



Oh, and this too. 

65 comments:

Marianne Elixir said...

Oh my goodness, Flo, you have me laughing SO hard. This is so very true and I love you for saying it out loud and with pictures. I love the idea of Messy Mondays. Mondays are usually our messiest, too, as I don't do any chores over the weekend.

At the moment, my life is such a "mess" that I am not sure I could regularly even post, but if you start something, I will try to contribute.

amanda said...

I've already had to apologize to my daughter twice today and to each boy once, and it's only 2pm. I may or may not have also cried at lunch.

I say yes to all of this. Yes yes yes. Write more, pretty please.

amanda said...

I've already had to apologize to my daughter twice today and to each boy once, and it's only 2pm. Also, I may or may not have cried at lunch.

I say yes to all of this. Yes yes yes. Write more often, pretty please.

Amy said...

I love this. thanks.

Erin said...

This was such a good blog Flo! Seriously so good. Thanks for sharing. Thanks for being honest. None of us are perfect. Sometimes I feel like the only one that's not perfect so it's good to know that we're all in this together.

Mrs. and Mama K said...

Good post! we all feel like we have to live up so some imaginary perfection of always having clean houses, scrumptious and healthy food, obedient and loving children, the perfect hair and outfit, etc. when all the people who appear this way are really just as lost and real as we are...lived-in homes, processed foods, sibling rivalry, cowlicks, and all. so nice when people post realness. :)

Corinne O'Sullivan said...

It's like you've been in my house. You got this spot on, especially the facebook for hours part. So sad. So true. So very, very true.

Btw, I dig your fridge ingeniousness.

Absolutely awesome post, I loved it!

Happy Girl said...

Grammie's relate to this blog too. I am not all sugar cookies and story time and my mama hood was like yours too.... And my car today? Ha.

Jenna said...

Beautiful, Flo. I think I've been longing to see a blog post like that for years. Totally cathartic. Thank you. (btw - I can totally top your front porch, anyday. right now mine has a christmas tree stand base, about 4 riding toys, an 8'x10' rolled up carpet, a dead mum and two lovely 2'x 3' maple boards that have been out there for 18 months because they're heavy and we don't know what we want to do with them).

Jenna said...

Beautiful, Flo. I've been wanting to read a blog post like that for years. Totally cathartic. Thank you. (BTW - I can top your front porch, anyday. Right now mine has a dead mum on it, a rolled up 8'x10' carpet, about 4 riding toys, a dog kennel and two 2'x3' planks of maple that have been leaning against the house for 18 months because they're heavy and we don't know what we want to do with them).

Jenna said...

Beautiful, Flo. I think I've been longing to see a blog post like that for years. Totally cathartic. Thank you. (btw - I can totally top your front porch, anyday. right now mine has a christmas tree stand base, about 4 riding toys, an 8'x10' rolled up carpet, a dead mum and two lovely 2'x 3' maple boards that have been out there for 18 months because they're heavy and we don't know what we want to do with them).

Christine said...

I cussed in front of my 18 month old this afternoon after I stepped in dog poo in our back yard. Meanwhile, she got her foot caught in a wooden pallet that's part of our lovely "garden path" and almost picked up a piece of said "poo" before I could get it with the shovel. Sigh. I almost burst our laughing several times reading your post, thank you, thank you, thank you! If you do Messy Mondays, I am in.
P.S. We don't know each other, but I used to live in Nashville and am good friends with Kierstin Casella and Katy Bowser and that's how I saw your post :)

Linda Boothe said...

Flo, thank you so much for this post and for being so open and candid, and for the great laughs. Although I am not a blogger, I have felt so defeated after reading blogs from moms you have described. I long to do things like making paint with my kids, sew with them, learn to knit with them, sew their clothes (it's such a joke because I have dozens of patterns for them and never actually finish sewing anything for them), and cook amazing meals. In reality I am barely able to keep up our little house and homeschool. Oh and you should see my back porch. I nearly cried one day when Eliana said to me, "Mommy, you never finish what you say you are going to do." Broke my heart.
I don't know if you have ever read Soulemama's blog, but she is just the sort of blogger you described. She used to title her Thursday blog entries "Corners of my home", and she would post photos of different lovely areas in her house. Well one day she admitted that her sweet husband had been threatening to start posting entries entitled "The other corners of my home". The ones with all the piles of laundry, and other messes. I laughed so hard when I read that and it helped me realize that she is imperfect just like the rest of us.

Anonymous said...

HILARIOUS!!!! Loved it and had me laughing so hard! Thanks you for reminding us all of the silly messes we all try to "clean up" and make beautiful. In the end you're right the love makes you forget it all.

jules of the east said...

Oh yes. Love hearing the truth from another mama-in-the-trenches. Thanks Flo : )

Katrina said...

Girl, can I tell you how much I now love you and follow you forever in spite of the fact that you don't know me. This is making my top 10 favorite posts ever. You said it. As someone who constantly posts her crappy pictures and doesn't have her face on the profile due to acne, I totally hear ya.

Wendy Davis said...

Flo, You rule it momma.

misschris said...

This is fantastic. And spot on.
Rock your banana peel cup, Flo. I'm going to go reheat my coffee (again) while the girls are playing upstairs with barbies.

Brecca Theele said...

Thank you for this, I too am just where you are at with three kids, IT'S UTTER CRAZiNESS!! The only reason I don't get real (or complain) online about it is because I will get a call from my mother every time asking if I am alright snooping asking what is wrong with me offering her quick cure. For my own sanity I have to avoid her Facebook calls and queries like the plague. Because all and all, even with the mess: I am happy & my kids are happy!

Brecca Theele said...

by the way we have the same issue with our refrigerator, so I am going to use your duct tape cure!!

christa said...

OH.YES. Thanks for this (and thanks to Alice Mary for sharing!) :)

Kathleen said...

Thank you for this story... I feel normal again!

Kathleen said...

Thank you for this story... I feel normal again!

Russellbunch said...

I am cracking up! I know every mom can relate to this. I have never started blogging, but when I blog in my head (which I do more often than I'd like to admit!) my blogs would look much more like this one than the Pioneer Womans! I will share this with my all my momma friends!

Kristi from NC said...

Thank you, thank you! I needed this today :).

Ryan Miller said...

Sweet mercy, I think I just startled my co-workers. Mostly with my laugh at the Christmas pic. And straight up grape jelly.

I was just thinking about this dichotomy last week as I was perusing Pinterest and wondering what most of the featured homes filled with sparkling lights and careful crafts look like on the other side of the camera or on different days.

On a side note, have you ever read dad blogs? And noticed that they're not as tidy?

Donna Lynne said...

And I am thankful that I continue to check your blog because when you do post it is magical! This speaks on so many levels!!!

Cara Ables Hicks said...

Real life is a beautiful thing. Thanks for sharing Flo!

Jan Bear said...

Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I'm a grandma raising a grandchild and never thought I did that well with the kids, but here I am, the best he's got, poor kid. All those "successful" moms just fill me with despair. It takes courage to step out of that picture of perfection and recognize that some people might mistake the message.

Did I say thank you?

Amber said...

So glad my friend Carrie linked your post to her FB page. This was yanked right from my heart. I think the majority of us can relate. I try to be real on my blog, but people still ask me, "How do you do it?" And I say, "Do what?" Then, I go on to explain as quickly as possible that my life can be and is often so, so messy. I tell them that I blog to hold myself accountable to continue being creative, to continue learning about God, to continue challenging my photography skills...


I could write on and on, but I will end by saying thank you. I shared your post on my FB page and hope everyone I know will read it.

Ellen @ Black and White and Loved All Over said...

What a perfect post! You are dead on. Thank you!

Jolanthe Erb said...

Love this post. And so very true. ;)

Jamie Willow said...

good stuff :) beauty is not always found in perfection, often it's found in the imperfect moments and how we handle them. Great reminder to keep it real.

Lynn "Flealips" said...

You just simply TOLD THE TRUTH without trying to make things look totally lovely when most of life just is NOT!

offsquare said...

Love it! xoxo

Monica Williams said...

Oh a standing ovation! Thank you for that post. It made me laugh and I totally GET it. Most of my life is a mess, I just forget to photograph that part!

Barbara said...

Thank you, thank you for this. You've inspired me in my own post today (http://www.luckypennymake.com/luckypennymake/2012/01/dreaming-of-order-in-a-chaotic-house.html) I so appreciate your honesty! And so funny, too, love it. The picture of your daughter in the cartoon shirt is priceless! Thank you again! - Barbara

Kaye Syrah said...

Beautiful! Bravo!

Another Music Mama said...

I found your post because a bunch of friends linked it on Facebook. Loved it. Wish I could send you a pic of my late-night wind-down time after I put the kids to bed and then sit on the couch shoving my face full of their Halloween candy while shopping online for Spanx. (True story.)

Custom Creatives said...

I absolutely love this blog post. I honestly always sit here, jealous of mamas out there are so domestic and goddess like, with their homeschooling, wooden toys and organic food which I can't afford. This post is a breath of fresh air! It's nice to know that I'm not the only mom out there who still buys my kids character clothing and doesn't make home made costumes every year (though I am going to try to this year with my new sewing machine, lol)

Elisabeth Cutrer said...

This was so refreshing--and a bit convicting since I tend to crop out the messy parts of our lives on my own "mom blog." I'm so glad that Heather shared this on FB so I could read it! Thanks for your honesty!

Nena Stopnik said...

I loved this post. So hilarious and so true. "What my cup overflows with is coffee...that I've stuck in the microwave 3786493 times because I'm freaking EXHAUSTED and I keep forgetting that it's in there." Thanks for keeping it real ;)

mrsbic said...

LOVE it! I actually really like the idea of messy mondays...and mondays are a great day for it too, when everything is in shambles! I think I'm going to do it on my blog...maybe it will get me blogging more!

Adventures In Babywearing said...

Love. And thank you.

Steph

Katie said...

What I love about this, is that there are 2 sides - not always the good, not always the bad. There is BALANCE. Mommy bloggers need to realize this. While there are those you speak of that are always "perfect" there are others who "hate" their kids all the time. Find some balance.

Kristin B. said...

I read this because my husband sent me the link. "You have to read it!" (He saw it on a friend's FB page.) You know when the husband says to read a mom blog that it's important. I loved it and have passed it on to others. Thanks! -Kristin in China

Flo Paris said...

Thank EACH of you so very much for reaffirming the fact that we are not alone in our mess. I love these comments and particularly the other glimpses of porches, less than perfect mama moments and generally messy lives.
I think this is even more important than I realized when I wrote the post. We NEED to let people in, to share our mess, to recognize it in others--I think it's vital to learning to be content whatever our circumstance.
So thank you, SO much for all of these words--they have encouraged me beyond measure.

zoe said...

thank you for this - i so needed it.... if this post hasn't already, i'm pretty sure it's about to go viral. my local mops' facebook page had posted it saying, "this has been floating around facebook" - so glad that it has! it's so easy to just paint the pretty picture and so tempting to let people believe that really are so perfect... thanks for being real!

Diana @ The Rader's Digest said...

Thank you. I started to write a similar blog post and deleted for fear I would be a "negative" blog mom and not "perfect". Thanks for reminding me. I ,too,feel just as you have described. I also feel that I enjoy all the stuff the other blogs teach, but when I go to post I feel less than -because I feel I don't have anything worthy to post about. (that my life is not quite perfect to blog about). I loved, Loved, loved, this post. I think I will stay awhile and follow.
I loved the ordinary photos, especially you at the computer. Because... that is real.
Thanks again,
Diana

Diana @ The Rader's Digest said...

Thank you. I started to write a similar blog post and deleted for fear I would be a "negative" blog mom and not "perfect". Thanks for reminding me. I ,too,feel just as you have described. I also feel that I enjoy all the stuff the other blogs teach, but when I go to post I feel less than -because I feel I don't have anything worthy to post about. (that my life is not quite perfect to blog about). I loved, Loved, loved, this post. I think I will stay awhile and follow.
I loved the ordinary photos, especially you at the computer. Because... that is real.
Thanks again,
Diana

Lil Muse Lily said...

this is so true! thank you. visiting through black&white and loved all over.
it's good to see that most of us mothers are all on the same boat.

Amanda Conley said...

Haha! Great blog post. I found this linked on Facebook. So glad I did. I completely identify.

Faith said...

LOVE this post! love love love love love! You rock for showing the normal side of life. Not the "tidied up because I'm posting this photo on my blog" stuff. And BTW my little man has been bugging me for a snack the entire time I've been writing this comment and I've said "we're going to the Library as soon as I finish this" like FIVE times.

Gombojav Tribe said...

Brilliant, Flo!

I can relate so much! I hate it when people ask me how I do it all. I always say, "I don't!"

That's why occasionally I post pictures on my blog of me matching an undignified amount of socks that I let pile up until no one has anything left to wear. Or a whole day or two worth of dishes because I was too lazy to wash them after each meal.

It's so important to me honest with ourselves that no one--least of all me--obtain the illusion we present to the world.

I think about that on Sunday mornings. Everyone looks so nice and happy. I wonder how many fought on the way to church in the car. How many unmade beds. How many sinks full of dishes. How many people took their clothes out of the dirty clothes basket and did the smell test and then wore them to church. :-) Oh yeah. It happens.

Thanks, Flo!

Kathy said...

I am laughing, but I am so comforted and encouraged. Sometimes I look at all am responsible and all that I want to accomplish and pass on and I can see logically that it just isn't possible. yet somehow I still give myself no other option than to do it all. I have been wanting to write a post like this for so long but my words never came together as well as yours. Hey!Wanna guest post for me? I'm not kidding. I want to be honest but I also want to protect my children from their sin not being permanetly etched in cyber space. I want to encourage others but also not scare you off. Such a fine fine balance, a lot like motherhood. And life for that matter.

Jebraun said...

Great post, Flo! Nobody has it all together and to pretend otherwise is a travesty to motherhood! Many times I feel like everybody else is doing a better job than me and I have to remind myself that God gave me MY kids, MY personality, MY penchant for loving to cook whilst hating to wash up after (makes for an interesting looking kitchen, I tell you!)Then I can take a deep breath and realise I'm a work in progress. Thanks heaps for your honesty that you too are a work in progress and showing all those great photos. Gave me a good giggle and will perhaps motivate me to clean the grime under the stove ;-)

Heyruthie said...

loved this post. just found your blog. will be reading you.

erica said...

so awesome, so honest, so my life. (except for the sewing and the homeschooling - hats off for even attempting!) rock on, flo.

stephanie said...

So real...love it

Abbie (Fox) Velez said...

Thank you Thankyou Thankyou So much!!!! What a beautiful piece about motherhood. Sometimes I listen to all of my friends talk about the million things they do and I go to their houses and see the cleanliness and then I think about my own life and the disasters and the pancake dinners and I just have to wonder how they do it and why I can't! What is wrong with me? I feel that this subject resonates with so many women out there. Super mom is an unattainable goal and we need to be happy and content with how our lives are on a daily basis and not how we wish they could be in a perfect world!

Lolo Linny said...

I love this. Thank you!

Anonymous said...

Best. Blog entry. EVER!!!

Crazymomma said...

Best. Blog entry. EVER!!!

ashley mac said...

Flo, this is amazing. Really LOVE it. Here's to breaking down some of the walls we put up with eachother as we assume everyone else has it more together than we do! blah. xoxo.

Traci said...

*sigh* I think I love you. <3 : D